| Pos | Players | Team | Round | Total Score | To Par |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||||
| 1 | Thomas Romano | Manhattan | 68 | 68 | -3 |
| T2 | Andrew Gain | Saint Peter's | 73 | 73 | +2 |
| T2 | Sean Fitzpatrick | Saint Peter's | 73 | 73 | +2 |
| T4 | Chris Calabro | Manhattan | 75 | 75 | +4 |
| T4 | Matthew Baney | Manhattan | 75 | 75 | +4 |
| 6 | Luke Previte | Saint Peter's | 76 | 76 | +5 |
| 7 | Nick Trill | Saint Peter's | 77 | 77 | +6 |
| T8 | Greg Nordtveit | Saint Peter's | 78 | 78 | +7 |
| T8 | TJ Sumigray | Saint Peter's | 78 | 78 | +7 |
| T10 | Billy Sues | Saint Peter's | 80 | 80 | +9 |
| T10 | Paul Toohey | Manhattan | 80 | 80 | +9 |
| 12 | Raymond Ferrari | Saint Peter's | 81 | 81 | +10 |
| 13 | Robert Thompson | Manhattan | 85 | 85 | +14 |
| 14 | Michael McGorty | Manhattan | 89 | 89 | +18 |
| 15 | Michael Villarosa | Manhattan | 102 | 102 | +31 |